Introduction to The Milk Pail
Nestled in the heart of Rice Lake, Wisconsin, The Milk Pail stands as a cherished local gem, renowned for its delightful offerings and vibrant community spirit. This beloved ice cream shop and eatery, located at 36 W. Marshall St., has become more than just a place to enjoy a sweet treat; it serves as a community hub where locals gather to savor both the flavors of Wisconsin and the warmth of shared moments. Under the new ownership of Alyssa Madlon, who took the helm in July 2024, The Milk Pail continues to thrive by embracing its rich history and adding fresh, locally sourced products to its menu.
The Milk Pail is celebrated for its commitment to supporting Wisconsin-made products, a testament to its dedication to the local economy and culture. From Cedar Crest ice cream to an array of meats and cheeses sourced from nearby artisans, the shop offers a true taste of the region. As you explore the comprehensive coverage of The Milk Pail’s offerings, operating hours, and unique features in this article, you’ll discover why it remains a staple in the Rice Lake community. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor, the inviting atmosphere and exceptional products make The Milk Pail a must-visit destination.
A Taste of Wisconsin – Ice Cream Selection
When you visit The Milk Pail in Rice Lake, WI, you’re in for a delightful treat, especially if you’re an ice cream aficionado. Known for offering an impressive range of Cedar Crest ice cream flavors, The Milk Pail ensures that every scoop is a celebration of Wisconsin’s rich dairy tradition. Cedar Crest, renowned for its pure premium, small-batch ice creams, provides a diverse selection that caters to every palate.
Here’s a peek at some of the most popular flavors you can savor at The Milk Pail:
- Blue Moon: A Midwest favorite, this bright blue ice cream is as mysterious as it is delicious, with a sweet, fruity flavor that’s hard to pin down.
- Butter Pecan: Rich and creamy with a buttery flavor, complemented by crunchy pecans.
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Ecstasy: A decadent mix of chocolate and peanut butter that’s sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.
- Mint Chocolate Chip: Refreshing mint ice cream with generous chunks of chocolate.
- Caramel Collision: A luscious blend of caramel swirls and chocolate chunks.
The Milk Pail also delights its customers with seasonal specials, offering unique flavors that rotate throughout the year. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic like Vanilla or something more adventurous like Amaretto Mackinac Island Fudge, there’s always something new to try. Don’t forget to check out their special ice cream challenges and sundaes, like the ‘Dirt’ or the ‘Brownie Sundae,’ for a fun twist on your dessert experience.
With such a vast array of flavors, every visit to The Milk Pail promises a new adventure, ensuring that both locals and visitors alike find their perfect scoop of happiness.
Beyond Ice Cream – Savory and Sweet Treats
While The Milk Pail in Rice Lake is renowned for its delectable ice cream selection, its menu extends far beyond frozen delights, offering a variety of savory and sweet treats that highlight local flavors. The eatery serves a delightful range of sandwiches, salads, and soups, each crafted with care and featuring local ingredients that celebrate Wisconsin’s rich culinary heritage.
Among the standout items on the Milk Pail Rice Lake menu are their grilled sandwiches and wraps, perfect for a hearty lunch. Options like the classic BLT with bacon, lettuce, and tomato on sourdough, or the Pastrami Reuben with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut on marble rye, offer a satisfying bite. For those seeking lighter fare, the Strawberry Fields salad with fresh strawberries, candied almonds, and house-made poppyseed dressing is a refreshing choice.
In addition to sandwiches and salads, The Milk Pail offers a selection of hearty soups, available from September through April, made from scratch using fresh, local ingredients. These soups are perfect for warming up on a chilly Wisconsin day.
| Menu Category | Standout Items |
|---|---|
| Sandwiches & Wraps | BLT, Pastrami Reuben, Turkey Club |
| Salads | Strawberry Fields, Caesar |
| Soups | Varies by season |
Complementing these savory offerings, The Milk Pail also features an array of local treats from Wisconsin artisans, including cheeses, meats, honey, jams, and chocolates. These products not only enhance the menu but also support local producers, offering patrons a true taste of Rice Lake’s vibrant food scene.
Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or looking to indulge in some local treats, The Milk Pail ensures a memorable dining experience with its diverse menu and commitment to quality ingredients.
The Milk Pail Rice Lake WI Hours
For those planning a visit to The Milk Pail in Rice Lake, WI, knowing the operating hours can help ensure a smooth and enjoyable experience. The Milk Pail offers a consistent schedule that caters to both early and late visitors throughout the week, with some seasonal and holiday variations.
| Day | Operating Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday – Thursday | 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Friday – Saturday | 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
It’s important to note that while The Milk Pail is closed on Sundays, it operates extended hours on Fridays and Saturdays, offering ample time for weekend indulgence. Additionally, special holiday hours are observed, such as reduced hours on Christmas Eve, opening from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM, and closing on Christmas Day to allow staff to celebrate with their families.
Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or an afternoon treat, these hours provide flexibility for enjoying all that The Milk Pail has to offer. Be sure to check their website or social media pages for any updates or changes to their schedule, especially during holiday seasons.
Visiting The Milk Pail – Address and Contact Information
Planning a visit to The Milk Pail in Rice Lake, WI, is made easy with all the essential details at your fingertips. Located at 36 W Marshall St., Rice Lake, WI 54868, this charming eatery is nestled in a convenient spot for both locals and visitors. For any inquiries or to place an order, you can reach out via phone at 715-719-0491 or email at [email protected]. These contact options ensure that your questions are addressed promptly, enhancing your experience.
To make your visit even more hassle-free, The Milk Pail offers ample parking space, allowing you to enjoy your time without the stress of finding a spot. Additionally, the location is surrounded by several local attractions, making it a perfect stop during your exploration of Rice Lake. Whether you’re planning a leisurely day or a quick stop, the accessibility and convenience of The Milk Pail are sure to enrich your visit.
To assist with navigation, here’s a handy Google Map link for easy directions: Find The Milk Pail on Google Maps. This tool will guide you directly to the heart of Rice Lake, ensuring your journey is smooth and enjoyable. So, when you plan to visit The Milk Pail Rice Lake, rest assured that all the details are covered for a delightful experience.
Supporting Wisconsin Artisans
The Milk Pail in Rice Lake, Wisconsin, is more than just a delightful eatery; it is a proud supporter of local artisans and producers. By partnering with a variety of local suppliers, The Milk Pail ensures that its offerings are not only fresh but also deeply rooted in the local community’s rich agricultural tradition. This commitment to local products not only enhances the quality of the menu but also strengthens the ties between the eatery and the surrounding community.
At The Milk Pail, you’ll find an impressive selection of locally sourced cheeses, meats, and other delicacies that highlight the best of Wisconsin’s artisanal craftsmanship. Here are some of the featured local suppliers that contribute to the unique dining experience:
- Wisconsin Cheese Makers: Renowned for their award-winning cheese, these artisans provide a variety of flavors and textures that are integral to The Milk Pail’s menu.
- Local Meat Producers: Offering high-quality, ethically raised meats, these suppliers ensure that every sandwich and salad is packed with flavor.
- Honey and Jam Artisans: These sweet additions come from local beekeepers and jam makers, adding a touch of natural sweetness to your meal.
- Chocolatiers: Indulge in locally crafted chocolates that provide a perfect end to any meal at The Milk Pail.
This dedication to supporting Wisconsin artisans is a testament to The Milk Pail’s philosophy of sustainability and community involvement. By choosing to source locally, The Milk Pail not only provides patrons with the freshest ingredients but also helps sustain the local economy and preserve traditional crafts.
So, when you visit The Milk Pail, you’re not just enjoying a meal; you’re experiencing a piece of Rice Lake’s vibrant local culture, crafted with care and pride by the talented artisans of Wisconsin.
Fresh Cheese Curds and Other Local Favorites
Imagine biting into a squeaky, fresh cheese curd—it’s a quintessential Wisconsin experience, and at The Milk Pail in Rice Lake, you can enjoy this local delicacy every Wednesday. Known for their freshness and flavor, these cheese curds are a must-try for both locals and visitors alike. The Milk Pail sources these curds from renowned Wisconsin cheese makers, ensuring that each bite is a testament to the state’s rich dairy heritage.
Beyond cheese curds, The Milk Pail offers a variety of other local favorites that capture the essence of Wisconsin’s culinary scene. From artisanal chocolates to locally made jams and honey, there’s a treasure trove of flavors waiting to be explored. These products not only make for delightful treats but also serve as perfect gifts or souvenirs to take home.
Here’s what some of our customers have to say about these local delights:
- “The cheese curds are the freshest I’ve ever tasted! I make it a point to visit every Wednesday just for them.” – Sarah L.
- “I love the variety of local products available. The honey and jams are a staple in my pantry now!” – Mark T.
- “The chocolates are divine. Perfect for a little indulgence or as a gift.” – Emily R.
These testimonials highlight the quality and appeal of The Milk Pail’s offerings, reinforcing its reputation as a haven for local culinary treasures. Whether you’re a cheese enthusiast or a fan of sweet treats, The Milk Pail in Rice Lake is sure to satisfy your cravings with its array of local favorites.
What Visitors Are Saying About The Milk Pail
When it comes to gauging the true essence of The Milk Pail in Rice Lake, Wisconsin, customer reviews on platforms like TripAdvisor and Yelp offer invaluable insights. These reviews reflect the genuine experiences of visitors, painting a vivid picture of what to expect when you step into this beloved local hub.
On TripAdvisor, many visitors praise The Milk Pail for its welcoming atmosphere and the quality of its offerings. A common theme among reviews is the exceptional taste of the Cedar Crest ice cream, with one reviewer noting, “The ice cream is a must-try, with flavors that are both unique and delicious.” Another reviewer appreciated the community-centric vibe, stating, “It’s more than just an ice cream shop; it’s a place where locals gather and feel at home.”
Yelp reviews echo similar sentiments, highlighting the friendly staff and the wide range of local products available. One satisfied customer mentioned, “The service is top-notch, and the variety of local treats is impressive. It’s a great place to unwind and enjoy quality products.”
Constructive Feedback
While the majority of reviews are positive, some visitors have offered constructive feedback. A few reviews mentioned the need for improved seating arrangements during peak hours, suggesting that additional outdoor seating could enhance the overall experience. Another reviewer pointed out the desire for extended operating hours, particularly on weekends, to accommodate late-night ice cream cravings.
Overall, customer feedback highlights The Milk Pail’s strengths in delivering high-quality products and fostering a sense of community. The constructive critiques provide valuable insights for potential improvements, ensuring that The Milk Pail continues to be a cherished destination for locals and visitors alike.
Awards and Recognitions
The Milk Pail in Rice Lake, Wisconsin, is not only a local favorite but also a recognized establishment in the community. Over the years, it has garnered several accolades that highlight its commitment to quality and community engagement. These recognitions serve as a testament to the establishment’s dedication to excellence and its role as a staple in Rice Lake.
Among the most notable awards, The Milk Pail has been celebrated for its outstanding contribution to the local food scene. It has received accolades such as the “Best Ice Cream Shop” in local surveys, solidifying its reputation for offering top-notch ice cream flavors that delight both locals and visitors alike. The recognition extends beyond just ice cream, as the eatery’s commitment to using locally sourced ingredients has earned it praise from food critics and patrons.
In addition to awards, The Milk Pail has been featured in various media outlets, further enhancing its visibility and reputation. Local newspapers and food blogs have highlighted its unique offerings and the warm, inviting atmosphere that makes it a beloved community hub.
These recognitions and media features underscore The Milk Pail’s dedication to providing exceptional service and high-quality products, reinforcing its status as a must-visit destination in Rice Lake. As it continues to thrive, The Milk Pail remains a shining example of how local businesses can make a significant impact on their communities.
Conclusion: Experience The Milk Pail
The Milk Pail in Rice Lake, Wisconsin, is more than just an eatery; it’s a vibrant community hub that captures the essence of local flavors and hospitality. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor, a trip to The Milk Pail promises a delightful experience filled with the best of Wisconsin’s culinary offerings. From the creamy indulgence of Cedar Crest ice cream to the savory delights of locally sourced sandwiches and soups, every visit is an opportunity to savor something special.
As you plan your visit to The Milk Pail, you’ll not only enjoy their delicious menu but also support a business deeply committed to its community. The shop’s partnerships with local artisans and producers ensure that every product is fresh and steeped in tradition. This commitment to quality and community is what makes The Milk Pail a beloved destination in Rice Lake.
We encourage you to follow The Milk Pail on their social media platforms for the latest updates, seasonal specials, and promotions. Staying connected will ensure you don’t miss out on any of the unique offerings and events that make The Milk Pail a staple in the community. For those interested in exploring plant-based options, consider checking out the top plant milk makers of 2025 for a sustainable and delicious addition to your culinary adventures.
So, whether you’re looking to indulge in a sweet treat, enjoy a hearty meal, or explore local products, The Milk Pail in Rice Lake is ready to welcome you with open arms. Experience the warmth, taste the tradition, and become a part of the community that cherishes this local gem.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the operating hours for The Milk Pail in Rice Lake?
The Milk Pail operates Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and Friday to Saturday from 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM. It is closed on Sundays.
2. What types of ice cream flavors are available at The Milk Pail?
The Milk Pail offers a variety of Cedar Crest ice cream flavors, including Blue Moon, Butter Pecan, Chocolate Peanut Butter Ecstasy, and seasonal specials.
3. How does The Milk Pail support local Wisconsin artisans?
The Milk Pail partners with local Wisconsin artisans to source cheeses, meats, honey, jams, and chocolates, emphasizing fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
4. What savory options are available on The Milk Pail’s menu?
The menu includes sandwiches like BLT and Pastrami Reuben, salads such as Strawberry Fields, and seasonal soups, all featuring local ingredients.
5. Where is The Milk Pail located and how can I contact them?
The Milk Pail is located at 36 W Marshall St., Rice Lake, WI 54868. For inquiries, call 715-719-0491 or email [email protected].